By: Dr. David Rabiner
Many parents, health care professionals, and educators agree that there is a pressing need to develop effective treatments for ADHD to complement or substitute for traditional medication and behavior therapy approaches. This is because such treatments do not work for everyone, important difficulties often remain even when these treatments are effective, and evidence for the long-term benefits of these treatments remains less compelling than one would like. In addition, in the case of medication treatment, some individuals experience intolerable side effects and many have concerns about taking ADHD medication for an extended period.
One alternative approach to treating ADHD has relied on the use of Compound Herbal Preparations (CHP) derived from traditional Chinese medicine. Practitioners of this approach believe that such preparations have important cognitive enhancing properties because they supply essential nutrients, fatty acids, phospholipids, amino acids, B vitamins, minerals, and other micronutrients that are important for optimal brain growth and development. As a treatment for ADHD, the idea is that many individuals with ADHD have deficiencies in essential nutrients that compromise healthy brain development and result in ADHD symptoms. Providing these nutrients via an appropriately prepared herbal compound thus has the potential to be therapeutic and reduce these symptoms.
This idea was tested recently in a randomized-controlled trial of a specific CHP for children with ADHD [Katz, Kol-Degani, & Kav-Venaki (2010). A compound herbal preparation (CHP) in the treatment of ADHD: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Attention Disorders. Published online on March 12, 2010.] Participants were 120 6–12 year-old children newly diagnosed with ADHD based on a comprehensive diagnostic evaluation. These children were all evaluated at the Sheba Medical Center, one of the largest university-affiliated tertiary care centers in Israel.
(Editor´s note: Dr. David Rabiner, author of this article, previously reviewed a 2005 meta-analysis whose findings need to be kept in mind to contextualize this new study. In the article Dietary Intervention for ADHD: A Meta-Analysis, Dr. Rabiner concluded that “Results from this meta-analysis provide strong evidence that the behavior of children with ADHD can be made worse by dietary factors, and that eliminating AFCs from their diets will, on average, result in behavioral improvements. This result is consistent with with accumulating evidence that neurobehavioral toxicity may result from a wide variety of distributed chemicals.”)
Children were randomly assigned to receive either the CHP (n=80) or a placebo (n=40) that was specially prepared to Read the rest of this entry »
By: Dr. David Rabiner
As noted in our Market Report, we expect the field of cognitive training (or “brain fitness”) software to grow in a variety of education and health-related areas over the next years. One of the most promising areas in our view: helping children and adults with attention deficits improve brain function to reduce ADHD symptoms.
I am glad to present this in-depth discussion on the results of two recent high-quality scientific studies. Let me start with Dr. Rabiner’s conclusion:
“Results from these two cognitive training studies highlight that cognitive training interventions may provide an important complement to traditional medication treatment and behavior therapy. Both studies included appropriate control groups, employed random assignment, and had outcome measures provided by individuals who were “blind” to which condition children were assigned to. They are thus well-designed studies from which scientifically sound conclusions can be drawn. They add to the growing research base that intensive practice and training focused of key cognitive skills can have positive effects that extend beyond the training situation itself.”
Without futher ado…enjoy the article!
- Alvaro
——————
Two New Cognitive Training Studies for ADHD Yield Promising Findings
– By Dr. David Rabiner
Although medication treatment is effective for many children with ADHD, there remains an important need to explore and develop interventions that can complement or even substitute for medication. This is true for a variety of reasons including:
Read the rest of this entry »
By: Dr. David Rabiner
A CDC report estimated that, in 2003, 4.4 million youth ages 4–17 lived with diagnosed ADHD, and 2.5 million of them were receiving medication treatment. Now, which is the core deficit underlying ADHD-so that treatments really address it? and how are ADHD and brain development related? Keep reading…
ADHD & the Nature of Self-Control — Revisiting Barkley’s Theory of ADHD
— By David Rabiner, Ph.D
As implied in the title of his book, ADHD and the Nature of Self-Control
, Dr. Barkley argues that the fundamental deficit in individuals with ADHD is one of self-control, and that problems with attention are a secondary characteristic of the disorder.
Dr. Barkley emphasizes that during the course of development, control over a child’s behavior gradually shifts from external sources to being increasingly governed by internal rules and standards. Controlling one’s behavior by internal rules and standards is what is meant by the term “self-control”.
Read the rest of this entry »
By: Dr. David Rabiner
(Editor’s Note: Neurofeedback is one of the technologies that people often ask us about. It is a promising intervention in a variety of areas, and has got significant traction in helping kids with ADD/ ADHD. Now, given the significant cost it poses for parents, we need to ask the question: “How Strong is the Research Support for Neurofeedback Treatment of Children with ADHD”? We are honored to present the thoughts of Duke University’s Dr. David Rabiner, a leading authority on the field, on that important issue. As a bonus, you will enjoy his detailed description and suggestions of how to design a high-quality scientific study.)
(Update as of March 2009: Dr. David Rabiner has written an update to the article below based on a newer study. You can read it clicking on link: New Study Supports Neurofeedback Treatment for ADHD)
————————————–
How Strong is the Research Support for Neurofeedback Treatment of Children with ADHD?
Neither of the two prominent approaches to treating ADHD — medication treatment and behavior therapy — are expected to effect long term changes in the child. Medication treatment induces short-term changes in brain activity that is associated with a reduction in symptoms for many individuals. Behavior therapy attempts to create a set of environmental contingencies that promote desired behavior in the child, but which is unlikely to endure when those contingencies are removed.
In recent years, researchers have begun devoting greater attention to the possibility that children — and adults — may be provided with particular kinds of experiences that may induce alterations in brain functioning that are associated with more enduring changes, i.e., they do not dissipate as soon as treatment ends.
Neurofeedback — also known as EEG Biofeedback — is reflective of this approach and has a history that goes back Read the rest of this entry »
By: Alvaro Fernandez
A blog carnival is a collection of good blog posts around a specific topic, published usually every 2 or 4 weeks. This time many carnivals included some of our articles, so we have a longer than usual list. Take a look at the topics you may be interested in.
The first 5 carnivals did the most creative work, in our view, to display all the content: Read the rest of this entry »
Recent Comments